Woodworking Talk banner

1 - 20 of 25 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,490 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
I was just about to run my last piece of Oak through the Planner and I noticed this. It was inside the board and not visible until I ripped it to 1/2" x 3/4”. The crack only about 6” long and the rest of the board is fine.

I just don’t want to make another trip to Home Depot to buy another board and I was just wondering if it can be fixed. I’ve been buying this stuff for a long time and this is the first for me to find a void inside the board with no visual signs. There were other boards in the rack like this, but they were visible from the outside.

I’m curious what caused this. Was it disease or water problems? it couldn’t be bugs because there were no holes.

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
26,333 Posts
The only solution for rotten oak is replaced oak. There is a lot of rot in an oak tree as it grows. A lot of them especially older trees the center of the tree rots out completely hollow. I had a tree on my place that the tree was more than 3' in diameter and it was like a big pipe. The wood was only about 3" thick.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,490 Posts
Discussion Starter #3
The only solution for rotten oak is replaced oak. There is a lot of rot in an oak tree as it grows. A lot of them especially older trees the center of the tree rots out completely hollow. I had a tree on my place that the tree was more than 3' in diameter and it was like a big pipe. The wood was only about 3" thick.
Thanks Steve, I was tempted to try filling it with wood putty and glue it down just to finish but I guess I'll just cut off the rotten part and put it in my scrap pile. I'll buy another board tomorrow, but I think I'll go to a different store.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,490 Posts
Discussion Starter #5
Cabinetman , I kind of hoping someone would suggest something. :laughing:
I really did not want to buy another board and its only 6" of bad.
I think I'll do that and them run it thru the planer and see what it looks like. Its only to cover up the edge of plywood anyway.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,490 Posts
Discussion Starter #8
I see a crack. I don't see any rot. Is it really rotted?
Compared to the other end, this end looks like it has micro termites.:smile:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,490 Posts
Discussion Starter #9 (Edited)
I also see a crack.....I'd try glue and clamp.
Yes it is crack and I’m not so concerned about that as I am with the soft part of the grain looking like mulch.
It’s not going to take a finish like this unless I can smooth it out with some filler. Otherwise it’s going to look full of holes like a sponge.

Actually the crack is not a crack but missing the soft grain which fell out like sawdust when I ripped it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
305 Posts
With a fungus or rot, there would usually be some kind of color change. Insects would leave holes or tracks.

The orientation of the crack looks like a wind shake. The other "soft" areas could be smaller shakes filled with sawdust from cutting. If this is the case, gluing and filling should work OK.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,490 Posts
Discussion Starter #11
I was looking for my oak colored wood filler, but it’s too old and I need a new can. I don’t know how much wood filler costs these days, but a new oak board cost $9, so it might be better to replace it if I’m only saving a few bucks.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,399 Posts
All depends on what you are going to do with this board... can you glue it and turn the piece so the crack doesn't need to be used on the exposed finished side of the project. Glue and fillers will show on a finished surface so buy a new piece of wood if that crack can not be used for a hiddened surface

If this post is for you to learn exactly what the cause of the defect is (bug, rot, moisture or stress crack etc...) let us see a end grain photo.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,490 Posts
Discussion Starter #13
This side is the worst side. The other side of the strip does not show the crack as much and could be glued in down. The other side has a graining surface that looks like it was sand blasted and is noticeable. I was going to finish it with clear polyurethane and maybe a thick coat will fill it in. Once I glue it down and it does show, I guess I could cut it out and glue in another piece afterward.

I guess I don’t really care that much as to the cause of it. I just don’t want to buy another like it. I went through about 10 boards before selecting this one and it was bad. It looked good before I cut it to size. I ripped about 1/8” of to get a straight edge before flipping it over for the finish cut and it wasn’t until I cut the exact length to size on the miter saw that it really showed or that I noticed it.

I just wished I knew before cutting the rest of the pieces, because I could have used it somewhere else, but oh well. I haven’t bought the boards for the doors yet and I think I’m going to buy them to the finished size and hope that this doesn’t show up again when I rabbit them. :huh:

Anyway it’s in the middle of the night and I got to go to work in another hour, so we’ll see what I end up with on my way home. LOL
 

·
Old School
Joined
·
24,027 Posts
I would check across the grain at the crack, and see if there is a differential in measurement on another area. If there isn't, gluing/clamping may cause it to be pinched. If that area is larger, then the gluing/clamping would be appropriate. Of course, if your piece was machined slightly out of parallel, that could account for a different dimension.






.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
26,333 Posts
If it was me I would replace the board. If the project is important I wouldn't knowingly put a piece of wood in it that you had to repair to use. If the repair fails the project may be ruined. Sometimes it's hard to see defects in wood especially when you are in a store shopping. I normally buy 20% more wood then the project needs so I can cut around the bad spots.
 

·
Old School
Joined
·
24,027 Posts
If it was me I would replace the board. If the project is important I wouldn't knowingly put a piece of wood in it that you had to repair to use. If the repair fails the project may be ruined. Sometimes it's hard to see defects in wood especially when you are in a store shopping. I normally buy 20% more wood then the project needs so I can cut around the bad spots.
The trick is to do repairs that don't fail. The piece could be replaced, but its replacement could look just fine, and have fissures that aren't noticeable, but fail later. Sometimes you just can't win.




.

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
26,333 Posts
The trick is to do repairs that don't fail. The piece could be replaced, but its replacement could look just fine, and have fissures that aren't noticeable, but fail later. Sometimes you just can't win.








.
I'm just seeing more going on with that board than the crack. There is a certain amount of rot there in the soft tissues of the end of the board enough some of it is coming out of the crack. It would be like a bad joint filling the void with glue to make up for the wood that is gone from the crack. I think there is a pretty good chance the repair would fail eventually. It would cost a few bucks to replace that board but he could use 90% of it on the next project. I don't think it's worth it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,490 Posts
Discussion Starter #19
I stopped at Lowes on my way home from work and bought a couple more red oak boards. The grain looks a lot better but not so straight, so I picked up the straightest boards they had. I don’t know where Home Depot gets their Oak from, but it’s a big difference in quality from Lowes.

It’s funny because I buy a lot of 4x8 sheets of Luan mahogany at HD and it’s so much better than the crap at Lowes. The quality is not always consistent though and sometimes I have to wait for the next shipment, but if it’s good I stock up. So I have to shop around and unfortunately Lowes and Home Depot are my only choices for wood here in the desert.

I would probably be more enthused in the fine woodworking if I had a better selection of woods. :yes:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
26,333 Posts
I stopped at Lowes on my way home from work and bought a couple more red oak boards. The grain looks a lot better but not so straight, so I picked up the straightest boards they had. I don’t know where Home Depot gets their Oak from, but it’s a big difference in quality from Lowes.

It’s funny because I buy a lot of 4x8 sheets of Luan mahogany at HD and it’s so much better than the crap at Lowes. The quality is not always consistent though and sometimes I have to wait for the next shipment, but if it’s good I stock up. So I have to shop around and unfortunately Lowes and Home Depot are my only choices for wood here in the desert.

I would probably be more enthused in the fine woodworking if I had a better selection of woods. :yes:
If you live anywhere near a major city I would look for a hardwood lumber company. You could probably get a better grade of wood for about 30% less than what you are paying the box stores. The box stores are just buying from one of them and doubling the price.
 
1 - 20 of 25 Posts
Top