Woodworking Talk banner

New woodworker looking for advice finishing a project

1101 Views 4 Replies 3 Participants Last post by  GCTony
*this post ended up very long , but I wanted to be descriptive with what I’ve done so far , so feel free to skip to the last couple paragraphs for the bulk of what I’m looking for help with *

Hi there , I am very new to this. I have made a few smaller tables and have had mixed results so far with finishing . I am working on a maple cookie coffee table right now , I’ve been working with limited supplies as I’m out of work right now due to covid and can’t justify buying too much new stuff rather than working with what I already have.

so this slab was dry and recently planed when I picked it up, with some odd burn marks from the planer on the top side . I filled some small Voids with epoxy on both sides allowing to harden before flipping , and did a light seal coat on the top side only if I remember correctly .

Once the epoxy was fully cured I scraped away as much as I could with a heat gun/ sunlight and scraper , and then I used 80 grit on my belt sander to even it out a bit more (I feel like this was a mistake , as I left some marks that were very hard to get rid of, maybe also the main cause of the uneven spots I will mention later ?) this was one of my first times using a belt sander and I feel I didn’t pay enough attention to speed, pressure, and grain direction .

once I noticed how much the belt sander was gouging I switched to my 5” random orbit sander (cheap black and decker ) and spent along time with 80 grit trying to remove some of those gouges . I feel like here I was also probably over focusing on rough spots and not moving evenly and consistently . Once I got the bulk of the marks out I then sanded more with the with 120 and 220 ( all I could afford / had available at my local store at the time )

sorry if this is super long , but anyway by this point I was pleased with how smooth the table felt , to my amateur eye the only thing that was really standing out were some residual burn marks from the planer , which Ihad already focused alot on and couldn’t seem to get rid of . I was hoping the finish would disguise this , and I also had a lot of small cracks leftover on top which I decided to leave and not do any further epoxy or filling work .I will also mention I filled some side cracks And random tiny voids with wood filler which I tinted a bit ( I wish I didn’t to this as it really stands out)

I thought about scraping out the wood filler and trying to fill some cracks with something more discreet , but then I decided to just go ahead with finish .
This was on overwhelming step as I had a can of osmo 1101 clear and 3043 clear , and had heard so many different application methods , most which were not available to me . Applied a coat of Osmo 1101 clear to the bottom side with a cloth , buffed in evenly by hand and wiped away after 30 minutes , wiping excess over the edges . Then I flipped it onto some cloths and did the same on the top side . Once I started wiping away by hand on the top side it was very sticky and hard to get off , so I grabbed my cheap automotive bugger with a pretty soft cloth bonnet and buffed away for ten minutes or so . It was looking pretty great to me at this point , I should note I was working outside in partial sunlight which I’m not sure about ? But in the sunlight I couldn’t really see any streak marks , a couple spots that seemed to be “dry spots “ which I hoped the second cost would handle . After a bit more research on the osmo website I decided to do the second coat on the top with 3043 clear Polyx oil, also applied with a cloth , buffed in by hand . This time I waited about 5 minutes and hit some of the spots that seemed to be soaking up more finish again. Buffed away with the soft cloth bonnet on car buffer .

so this is where I’m at with it now. The second coat has sat for about 3 or 4 days and I’ve been careful not to touch the top with bare hands as I saw on some YouTube video you have to wait up to two weeks to handle some osmo products ( is that true ? This stuff seems too complicated for me at this point in my experience )

I’m pleased with how it looks overall , but I’m a perfectionist by nature so I can’t help but notice some dry spots, inconsistencies in the finish maybe some low spots I created by spending too long in certain areas , I’ll include some pics and try and show these areas as much as possible I’m trying to decide / figure out whether at this point after 2 coats of finish I can / should fix any of these problems . I purchased the hot stuff/ super t/ special t glue set and a bigger variety of sandpaper. I was thinking maybe I could fix some of the dry spots with the glue but I’m not sure how to go about that with 2 coats of finish on , and the low spots . Any help or advice would be greatly appreciated !
426506
426507
426508
426509
426510
426511
See less See more
6
1 - 5 of 5 Posts
Welcome to the forum! Is there a cabinet shop nearby that can do your sanding on their wide belt sander? A couple of passes will do it and you'll get a lot better result, won't have to use your belt sander. You can just finish up with your ROS. I've not used that finish so can't help you with that. One photography tip I would give you is to clean your lens.

It's a nice looking table, btw.

David
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Welcome to the forum! Is there a cabinet shop nearby that can do your sanding on their wide belt sander? A couple of passes will do it and you'll get a lot better result, won't have to use your belt sander. You can just finish up with your ROS. I've not used that finish so can't help you with that. One photography tip I would give you is to clean your lens.

It's a nice looking table, btw.

David
Thank you! I have yet to find one but I will do some more research on that for sure. Can you still do that kind of thing once you have applied a finish like this? Or are you just saying that would be the better option from the start for next time? I feel like at this point I should maybe just apply one more coat of finish and call this one done, maybe sell it to a friend for a good price or keep it as a learning piece .
Next time. For this one I would keep on the path you've chosen and call it finished; it looks nice. We all tend to be more critical of our own work than others viewing what we've done.

David
I don't know anything about the finish you used but I think it looks pretty darn good, maybe another coat?? Like difalkner said, we tent to be overly critical of our own work.
1 - 5 of 5 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top