Woodworking Talk banner

Multi-tool reveiw

28K views 46 replies 32 participants last post by  StephenD  
#1 · (Edited)
Ok I know have said many many time how Harbor Freight power tools are junk. Well after pricing out the Mult-tool that fein makes and Dremel as well, I was picking up a paint gun and saw HF has a multi-tool for $39.00. For that price I bought it. Used the halfmoon blade to cut the sheetrock out were we are building a shower. My $39.00 investment was well worth the chance I tool buying it. It cut through the 1/2 sheetrock almost as fast as my recip-saw with hardly any dust. Then I change the blade to the scraper blade and pealed up two layers of vinyle flooring. It wasn't as fast as they show the fein doing it on tv but it did the job. It cames with 4 different attachments, one was a 3" triangle sanding pad, two for sawing and one for scraping. It has a 1/4 hp motor with a 6ft power cord.
I only have one negitive thing to say about it. The shape and size of the body is a little hard to hold. Too fat for my hand. Other than that I would give it a 8 out of 10. As for how long it will last, We will see. But for what it saved me in time and clean up, It paid for it's self on this last job.
 

Attachments

#4 ·
Handy,
My brother in law has the HF tool. He likes it. I bought the dremel not too long ago and have a few chances to use it on the last few jobs I have done. I have been cutting trim in place that has to have say a 1/2" taken off. Draw a line and follow the line, works great. I used it to cut holes for electrical boxes in the backs of cabinets. It is kind of amazing how it cuts through wood. Very fun to use.
Mike Hawkins;)
 
#5 · (Edited)
Just got one as a birthday present from my little brother. I actually was gonna take it back and exchange it with something else. I was at work and needed to cut a corner out that was in a pretty tight spot. So I broke it out and tried it out. I was stunned at how well it was built and how well it functions. The sanding pads were pretty much junk though.
Does HF or Fein or Dremel use the same attachments?
 
#12 ·
Allthumbs I have looked at the Dremel and the one sears sell, and mine form HF and all three of take different blades. As far as I can see, you will have to buy the blades made for each brand.
 
#7 ·
After reading this thread I visited the closest HF, and bought one, with a couple replacement blades.

The blades themselves have 4 holes in a + sign configuration around the center allen key bolt. There are no corresponding pins to hold the blade firmly in place. In my experiments, the cutting saw blade would spin off center, and the bolt loosened with the vibration.

So I centered it again and really torqued the bolt down again. It still loosened up and the blade rotated.

So I wound up drilling a small hole in the base of the tool, and screwing in a little machine screw and grinding off the head.
Problem solved.

But I didn't account for the fact that the tool doesn't stop perfectly centered and thus my machine screw is not perfectly centered and the blade slightly offset.

But it does work pretty well. It cut through the corner of a 2x4 about 5/8 inch deep in around 5 seconds.
 
#10 ·
I started this thread about the same type of tool.
http://www.woodworkingtalk.com/f12/...k.com/f12/dremel-multi-max-vs-fein-multimaster-vs-rockwell-sonic-crafter-10557/

The Fein is expensive because they had a patent on it until last fall. Since the patent expired there is a plethora of oscillating tools. Dremel, Rockwell, and Bosh now make similar tools as well as the HF. (I bet Ryobi and Craftsman won't be far behind)

And here is a thread comparing all of them:
http://www.toolsnob.com/archives/2008/10/dremel_dremel_multimax_oscilla.php
 
#17 ·
As for how long it will last, We will see. But for what it saved me in time and clean up, It paid for it's self on this last job.
When you buy something from HF that is electric it generally comes with a 90 day warranty. For the $39 item it probably would cost like $5-$9 more to get a 1-3 yr replacement warranty. I don't buy allot at HF but if I do I buy the heavy duty model if possible or get the warranty. I have a $7 brad nailer a $30 coil nailer and a $50 framing Gun that are all used for 3 years and no problems. I have a 20" 1 1/2 hp production drill press, there biscuit jointer and of course a ton of clamps also all over 3 yrs old and no problem. But I used their miter saw and its not worth it. I also have a 29 Gal 4hp twin piston compressor that works well except for the regulator switch is crap and I plan on replacing it.
 
#20 ·
Fein MultiMaster

The Fein MM is a wonderful tool; the newest model is even better, as the star-shaped shaft holds the blades very reliably compared to older round shaft.

The issue for me was the cost of the blades; they were VERY expensive, and in light of the cost, I thought their longevity was only average. SO, TWO QUESTIONS:

1) How often are you going to use it?

2) How good are the blades and scrapers compared to their price?
 
#22 ·
Hammerhead After using my HP multi tool and loving it my boss bought the Bosch cordless 12 volt multi tool. Cant tell you the model number of it. What I do like about it is it come with an adapter plate that allows you to use almost any brand blades. The bosch has a row of pins that hold the blade in place. He went to buy the dremel at lowe's but saw they had a bosch cordless. He already has a whole set of bosch tools that take the same battery.
I looked at the one sears sell today and it is about the same size as the dremel, but the sears one has a blade that won't fit any other brand. So I wouldn't buy the sears model. We buy replacement blades at HP because the sheetrock half moon blade is around $5.00. The same blade at Lowe's is almost $19.00
 
#23 ·
When I bought mine, I figured it would be a fluke if I ever used it. Well last week, I installed a new microwave and had to trim 1/4" off the top of the splash between two upper cabinets (for 30"). It was mica laminate on 3/4" plywood up against a stucco wall. It took about 10 minutes, but was easier to do than any other method. It cut nice and clean up against the cabinets.

I wish I had it recently when I had to notch a baseboard for a toe kick. Easier than a chisel and a hammer. The size of it is OK, fits my hand comfortably. Does get a bit hot.

We should start a Multi-Function Tool club, and have meetings, serve coffee and doughnuts, and each of us could get up and introduce ourselves and tell our unique stories.:laughing:






Image
Image
 
#24 ·
What time are the meetings?

And do you have to own one? Can you just gawk without participating? How much are dues? What kind of donuts, cream filled are my favorite? Will others bring their worn out blades? How hot does yours get? What brand is it and how much did it cost and where did you buy it? How long have you had it? heh..heh :laughing: bill
 
#27 ·
I've held both the Bosch and the Dremel. I like the feel of the Bosch. My wife did too; it's narrower and fit her smaller hand well. We usually do remodeling projects together and believe the multi-tool tools could be useful. If Bosch has not come out with a corded model before our next project we may just go with the cordless Bosch.

[We have the Bosch driver (not the impact driver) that uses the same batteries. We love that driver. :yes: ]

Handyman - thanks for the info about blades ;)
 
#29 · (Edited)
This is NOT that multi-tool

Did you read any of the above posts before you answered?
Are you selling these? :thumbdown: If so, it's not allowed. :no:
 
#30 · (Edited)
I bought the Rockwell a couple of months ago and have been very pleased with it, although it does run awfully hot sometimes. They warn about that, particularly at low speeds.

I've played w/ all the attachments and used a couple in projects and they all work very well.

Can't even remember now why I chose it over the Dremel. The HF sounds like a good deal if it lasts for a substantial amount of use.
 
#33 · (Edited)
I agree with glassyeyes. I bought a Fein when they first came out. Great for remodeling and it paid for itself the first job I did with it. BUT!!! the replacement blades are expensive. The average around $35 to $40.00. I can't buy them locally and have to order them. For the price of two replacements, I bought the Dremel from Lowe's. Replacements are cheaper and I can buy them here. Both work great. My last project was refinishing an old dresser I bought at an auction. The sander attachment was great for getting into the tight corner without messing up the old detail work.