Woodworking Talk banner

Hardwood drilling automation

415 Views 4 Replies 5 Participants Last post by  Biotec
2
Hi Guys,

I need tο drill stepped holes in hardwood that are as co-axial as possible. Since I want to avoid work holding repositioning as much as possible, I came up with the following automation.

My problem is estimating the spindle requirements, considering the custom, stepped, bit (see picture). Will a cheap 2.2kw (3hp) 24rpm spindle OK? Do I even need a spindle with a VFD or a fixed-speed motor would do the job cheaper?

The cycle time is not critical.

I'd love to hear your thoughts!
Brick Rectangle Font Urban design Art
Cross Font Symbol Parallel Rectangle
See less See more
1 - 5 of 5 Posts
With proper fixturing it would not be an issue to do one end at a time. Even drilling the stepped hole in two opertions Using a forstner bit first for the big hole then a regular bit for the small hole. I would start with a long "V" block to hold the piece of wood that is to be drilled. If you have a floor standing drill press you could turn the table 90 degrees, attach your fixture and drill away. Getting the table to 90 degrees would be a fairly simple matter with a dial indicator. My time spent in a factory as a machine setup,QC and a little tool & die taught me a lot about fixturing.

Ken
EDIT: I would make the sides of the "V" block wide enough to give support to the engine side of the piece of wood being drilled. Not the skinny support you have pictured. With my setup I would mark the wood so the same corner always is against the fixture.
Are the dimensions of the drill tool Imperial or metric?
The illustration of the machine shows the spindle motors with collet chucks, needed for the more accurate tool centering required for slot milling, rather than Jacobs chucks typically put on a drill spindle. Router spindles run at much higher spindle speed than is normal for drilling. They work with carbide tools that withstand much higher temperature, and they will fry steel drills. Also, drill spindles are much less expensive than router spindles since they don't need super precision high speed bearings capable of handling radial as well as axial cutting force. Router spindles are usually run on high frequency power and don't cool themselves well at lower spindle speed.
I don't know if the length of the workpieces will vary. The illustration shows the positioning and tool movement both using the same track. Automated drill spindles frequently have the tool movement built in and can be positioned on less expensive ways that don't need to be hardened and ground for precision accuracy and durability.
What's your estimate of the production volume?
See less See more
I need tο drill stepped holes in hardwood that are as co-axial as possible. Since I want to avoid work holding repositioning as much as possible, I came up with the following automation.
Excellent build design. Your design insures the drills are coaxial, therefore the holes will be coaxial.
Repositioning the workpiece does nothing more than add more error and effort into the process.

My problem is estimating the spindle requirements, considering the custom, stepped, bit (see picture). Will a cheap 2.2kw (3hp) 24rpm spindle OK? Do I even need a spindle with a VFD or a fixed-speed motor would do the job cheaper?
Yes a collet system is a very good choice for both accuracy and tool retention. A fixed length spindle also is much more accurate than any spindle which is required to extend and retract.

I question your stated "24RPM", is that a typo? Seems extremally slow for your given drill size.

While a fixed speed motor may work, the surface speed difference, in the drill diameter to the counterbore diameter, may make choosing the best RPM an exercise in frustration. A variable speed motor would give you the opportunity to "fine tune" and dial in your speed to fit conditions. You could even program a faster RPM for the drill and then slow the RPM once the counterbore diameter enters the workpiece.
If chip evacuation is an issue a change in RPM may cure that or adding a peck cycle would be another option.

Other than that IMHO, you have done an excellent job.

note As to my qualifications; I spent a career in a tool and die shop where our sole "product" was to design and build one of a kind, custom machinery, for a wide variety of industries. From simple fixtures, to muti-station fully automation machining, drilling, assembly and packaging equipment.
See less See more
@deemoss good day.

you did not say if was a one time run of a few parts like 20 or production of 500 or more.

the reason i ask is how i would approach the problem. a low cost solution or investment in to production equipment with long term jigs and tooling.

like two routers on side with end mill bits they would slide toward the work and the fixture would be fixed position and rotate with an indexing. just a start.
1 - 5 of 5 Posts
Top