Butcher block oil vs conditioner?too dark
1 - 20 of 20 Posts
Joined
·
28,393 Posts
Yes, even water would darken it. It's just dark wood.
But the regular mineral oil will be alittle lighter? Is there anyway to remove the oil so I can do the whole thing with the same kind of oil? It just made it so the Purple Heart and paudak look the same. Kind of makes it look a mess to me.
Joined
·
7,222 Posts
This is an end grain board. The cells are open on end grain and will absorb any oil or as Steve mentioned, even water would make the wood look dark.
The butcher block conditioner is a mix of wax and oil. The oil part will darken the woods.
End grain purpleheart becomes very dark with oil. Padauk may be dark, and will get darker with exposure to UV.
A thread some months back on end grain boards and oil vs wax by TomC who did not like how dark the wood became with oil.
TomC stripped back to bare wood and then applied beeswax which did not make the wood as dark.
You can try cleaning off with solvent, but I expect you will also need to sand to expose fresh wood.
http://www.woodworkingtalk.com/f2/end-zgrain-cutting-boards-51699/
The butcher block conditioner is a mix of wax and oil. The oil part will darken the woods.
End grain purpleheart becomes very dark with oil. Padauk may be dark, and will get darker with exposure to UV.
A thread some months back on end grain boards and oil vs wax by TomC who did not like how dark the wood became with oil.
TomC stripped back to bare wood and then applied beeswax which did not make the wood as dark.
You can try cleaning off with solvent, but I expect you will also need to sand to expose fresh wood.
http://www.woodworkingtalk.com/f2/end-zgrain-cutting-boards-51699/
First and foremost, I think it looks great as it is. I know you wanted more contrast between the padauk and the purpleheart, but there's lots of other contrasting pieces in there to add interest and the purpleheart and padauk may very well change in time anyway. I think you could get the old finish out by repeatedly washing it down with naphtha, but keep in mind that the naphtha will be getting into the pores you're trying to get the oil/conditioner out of. If you're planning to use it for actual food preparation, that's not good. Also, naphtha is very flammable, so be careful if you decide to use it.
Joined
·
1,494 Posts
Looks good to me :thumbsup:Hey all I just finished a cutting board and put Howard's butcher block conditioner on the bottom and it made it way too dark. Will regular mineral oil be lighter?
Always test your finish on an offcut of the workpiece .
If the product has any colour at all , it will add colour to the work as well as darken it
Joined
·
1,494 Posts
Are you going to be using it at home ?
Joined
·
216 Posts
If you use it for a while, especially if you wash it now and then, the butcher block will lighten up again before too long...at least, that's been my experience.
It looks great...I can see the difference between the darker woods already!
It looks great...I can see the difference between the darker woods already!
Joined
·
1,494 Posts
No , not at all .
(Well not if you keep it out of the oven , the microwave , the dishwasher , and scalding hot water .
It does happen :laughing: )
Don't wipe it clean or dry with cloth or wash in soap , detergent or dishwashing solutions.
Scrub it with a stiff plastic bristle brush while holding it under hot running water and leave it to drain dry .
Store in the open light.
As said above , the surface will fade in time .
The mineral oil that has penetrated deep into the wood will prevent fat and grease from getting in and going rancid etc.
Joined
·
28,393 Posts
If it were me I would keep it oiled from time to time. Not oiling the cutting board will allow the water to penetrate further into it causing more expansion and contracting causing it to crack.
Joined
·
1,494 Posts
Wiping can lift off oil that may have risen to the surface ,
letting it dry naturally will allow that oil to draw back in .
Wiping with cloth can become a habit , and lead to using a damp cloth to clean it , when dirt and grease can get driven into the timber.
When you first oiled it , did you saturate it so that puddled oil had to soak in , or just give it a wipe and a polish ?
Joined
·
1,494 Posts
I know that that's the old way of doing things with raw linseed oil ,
is it the normal process for butcher block conditioner ?
1 - 20 of 20 Posts
Join the discussion
