Woodworking Talk - Woodworkers Forum

Woodworking Talk - Woodworkers Forum (https://www.woodworkingtalk.com/forum.php)
-   Power Tools & Machinery (https://www.woodworkingtalk.com/f12/)
-   -   Which screw head design: SQ, Torx, phillips ACR, Spax (https://www.woodworkingtalk.com/f12/screw-head-design-sq-torx-phillips-acr-spax-60568/)

1023sluser 02-27-2014 11:38 AM

Which screw head design: SQ, Torx, phillips ACR, Spax
 
I've been using McFeely Square heads for a while. I like them, but have gone through a boat load of bit drivers because they become rounded way too soon as far as I'm concerned. Been buying them in 6 packs. With impact drill drivers it's even worse. You can buy hardened bit drivers like the Wiha bit drivers at over $9.00 ea. But I've heard others have had this problem and maybe have found some of the other design screw heads work as better solutions for the new impact drills. Would appreciate hearing from people who have had the same problem as I have and found a better answer. Hate to give up on McFeely, but they've been recently bought out and I'm concerned their screws and bits which will now be made in China will not be what they used to be. Trying to keep ahead of the game. Thanks.

ryan50hrl 02-27-2014 11:57 AM

I like torx bits and screws, but square drive are almost as good for me. Oddly I don't think I've ever rounded over a square drive bit, I think with my recent floor tiling project I went through about 1500 screws and never changed the bit.

tvman44 02-27-2014 12:05 PM

I have been using square drive for years with no problems. I heard McFeeleys had been bought out but did not know their screws would be coming from china, was fixing to order a bunch of screws but may have to rethink where to get them. :censored:

1023sluser 02-27-2014 12:07 PM

Since this was a first post I hadn't noticed "Similar posts" below. They took care of answering most of my question. Looks like Torx and/or Sq. drive are about equally liked with Torx maybe a hair more so. Too bad the Robertson Sq drives aren't as readily available in the US. I have a hardened Wiha drive on order and will see if that solves some of the rounding problem I've had. I have a drawer full of old slightly rounded #1 and #2 sq. drive bits.

Tom King 02-27-2014 06:11 PM

TORX is my first choice when I can get it in a size I need. I've never had a rounding problem, and you can not only get them in, but back out, which is not always the case with even a square drive.

SeniorSitizen 02-27-2014 07:45 PM

I estimate 99 percent of screw and bit problems are caused by assembly preparation technique.

Miller Woodworks 02-27-2014 10:36 PM

If you can hold the bit properly in the screw, torx or square drive will work well for you. I've never rounded either of those bits unless I messed something up, like using a bit a size too small.

rrich 02-28-2014 01:23 AM

I have to agree with Mr. Miller. If you use the appropriate size driver, the drivers should last almost forever.

tip: There are two types of driver bits. One type is two part metal with what appears to be a hardened tip while the other type is a single piece of metal. The former last for years while the latter is best bought in lots of 50 on special at Lowe's.

One other thing. There are screws that are combination Robertson and Phillips. Regardless of driver bit, neither work very well.

cabinetman 02-28-2014 09:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SandburRanch (Post 579903)
I estimate 99 percent of screw and bit problems are caused by assembly preparation technique.

+1. :yes: I agree that there's more to driving screws than just the screw head (whatever type), and the tool. There may need to be a correctly sized pilot hole, and countersinking where necessary helps. Keeping the bit in the head seems to be the problem. If the tool... whether it be a cordless drill, or a handheld driver of some sort is used, the screw should be perpendicular to the subject piece, and the driver held in that same line.

I use a cordless drill (for most applications) on slow speed. When the screw is almost tight, I just bump the trigger to pull up tight. I don't drive it fast until it stops. That's what heats up the screw, snaps off heads, and over spins them when seated, and likely makes their holding strength less than predictable.






.

FrankC 02-28-2014 11:27 AM

There is also now undersized bits available for coated square head screws, which work better for them but don't work well with plain screws.

unclefester 02-28-2014 02:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cabinetman
+1. :yes: I agree that there's more to driving screws than just the screw head (whatever type), and the tool. There may need to be a correctly sized pilot hole, and countersinking where necessary helps. Keeping the bit in the head seems to be the problem. If the tool... whether it be a cordless drill, or a handheld driver of some sort is used, the screw should be perpendicular to the subject piece, and the driver held in that same line. I use a cordless drill (for most applications) on slow speed. When the screw is almost tight, I just bump the trigger to pull up tight. I don't drive it fast until it stops. That's what heats up the screw, snaps off heads, and over spins them when seated, and likely makes their holding strength less than predictable. .

+2. Correct pilot holes solve most issues from splitting wood, screw breakage and heads being stripped. I really like they tapered drills with the countersink all in one. Clean look and it is less time for me with the double handling than the repair from the last screw I drove in splitting the material.

I've had pretty good success using a cordless impact driver on slow speed with a quality bit.
I have had problems with bulk bits stripping out hanging drywall. Now that's some junk.

Steve Neul 02-28-2014 02:17 PM

I really don't care which screw type they use. I wish the world would pick ONE and ban the rest. It's getting where you have to carry a pocket full of different drive bits to work on anything.

1023sluser 02-28-2014 02:33 PM

Another factor to consider
 
I think all your points have good merit. There are a couple more points to accomplish "best woodworking practices" I think that haven't been stressed or mentioned that in my readings are worthy of mention. I've read about others who have had their square driver bits and others get rounded over too quickly, or snap off when not expected. The relatively new shift to impact drivers puts a lot more force on the bit and screw head than before. Cheap Chinese metals creeping into the manufacturing process to reduce cost or just cheaper USA metals to accomplish the same end? You have to be ever more watchful of blending your purchases to match your equipment selection nowadays it seems. impact drivers with no torque selection or little torque selection may be cheaper, but not overall as functional. When I made my change from a DeWalt 12v system to the Milwaukee 18v fuel system, one of the factors that sold me was the 3 fold torque control capability. I've used the lower torque setting on some projects and was glad I had it. I guess I could have bought a Harbor Freight 18v system for much less without that torque control, but after having it: it's better to have and not want, than to not have and wish you had...Perhaps we need the companies to develop screws, drill drivers etc. to match the new equipment better. Then again, I've always been a dreamer. Love your input guys. thanks!

johnep 03-01-2014 03:40 AM

I use Pozidrive which are a variation on Phillips.
johnep

Manuka Jock 03-01-2014 04:17 AM

As well as the variables of metal quality in screws and driver bits , and of screwdrivers , both machine and manual ,
there is the totally unpredictable one of the timber being used .

Matching up screws to bits for a firm fit as well as metal quality helps , as does pre drilling , and consideration for machine speed and torque.

And leave the impact driver in it's case . It is for use with hex head fasteners , not finishing screws .

Personally , I'm waiting for the advent of triangle-head screws ;)

cabinetman 03-01-2014 06:02 AM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Manuka Jock (Post 580428)

Personally , I'm waiting for the advent of triangle-head screws ;)

There is a 3 wing...close to a triangle...
.
Attachment 90042






.

Manuka Jock 03-01-2014 06:07 AM

look at the buggas ,
28 of them eh , 2 more and we have the full set of 30
:laughing:


The tri wing , seen them , never used them , how do they stand up to scrutiny ?

1023sluser 03-01-2014 07:57 AM

I think it's OK to use the impact driver on those finishing screws IF...you also have adequate torque control on that tool.

Steve Neul 03-01-2014 08:05 AM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Manuka Jock (Post 580428)
As well as the variables of metal quality in screws and driver bits , and of screwdrivers , both machine and manual ,
there is the totally unpredictable one of the timber being used .

Matching up screws to bits for a firm fit as well as metal quality helps , as does pre drilling , and consideration for machine speed and torque.

And leave the impact driver in it's case . It is for use with hex head fasteners , not finishing screws .

Personally , I'm waiting for the advent of triangle-head screws ;)

You mean these?

Manuka Jock 03-01-2014 10:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steve Neul (Post 580453)
You mean these?

Interesting , but no cigar .
They're not woodscrews , but thats the idea . The driver bit would be the same


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 04:48 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2020, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2020 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
vBulletin Security provided by vBSecurity v2.2.2 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2020 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.

 
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome