It was Electric Motor Works that diagnosed the issue. We talked at length about what might have happened, etc. They had looked for a replacement and even had an estimate of rewiring done. I don't remember asking them what the frame number was so maybe I'll make a trip back there. The frame number is supposed to be printed on the tag on the motor but maybe in 1995 that wasn't required.
Thank you for your effort, unfortunately the 145Y specs are for a 3/4 inch shaft (mine is 7/8) and the output shaft is too short. It sure looks like it should fit though? I also looked at the Grizzly H5387 and it is close also.
Sunny-- Oh how I wish it was just that. The wiring is gone (see pic).