Buying new router....maybe - Woodworking Talk

kziggy · 03-12-2009, 05:25 PM

Below are some specs from a Porter-Cable router I am considering. Price is right - a little over $100.00 w/o case. Money is a concern like it is with most Americans today, but I am also concerned with performance. Also, this model requires double wrenches to secure a shank bit in the collet. I've always had routers that had a locking device for the shaft so that you could remove a bit with one wrench but, in fact, I had a Craftsman locking device strip out on me.

I would appreciate any comments you may have on this router or any suggestions on any other brand that might be in that $100 to $150 range. Also, any concerns about needing the double wrenches for the collet?

One other question - While I realize I would be looking at more $$$, are the router kits with the plunger attachment worth the investment?

Thanks - Ken

"Porter-Cable 690LR 11 Amp Fixed Base Horsepower Router
The Porter-Cable 690LR 11 Amp fixed base router utilizes a hefty 1-3/4 HP motor to generate a mind-blowing 27,500 RPM for ultra-precise cuts. The micrometer depth adjuster keeps things incredibly precise to 1/128 of an inch. To ensure years of top-notch performance, the 690LR is equipped with a dust-sealed switch and sealed ball bearings to keep dust out. The included collets will accept 1/4-inch and 1/2-inch shank bits. Routing is made easy with the dual, ergonomic rubber handles strategically mounted on the router for easy, comfortable operation."

skymaster · 03-12-2009, 05:30 PM

pc 690 family is the standard that all other routers try to equal :}:}
Yes best buy is the kit with the plunge base.

firehawkmph · 03-12-2009, 05:37 PM

Kzig,
I am not that familiar with every porter cable, but just from looking at the specs, that router will fit the bill for a lot of different projects. Really depends what you want to use it for. For decorative edging, pattern routing, dados, etc., it should work fine. If you decided you wanted to use some of the large raised panel cutters, you would be wise to seek out a more powerful (3hp+) router. As far as the plunge goes, it can come in handy at times for particular types of cuts that require you to start inside the edges of a piece of wood, say maybe a mortise, or sink cutout. You should be able to buy that separate from PC at a later date if you decide you have a need for one. As far as the two wrenches go, I find it easier than a single wrench setup. I put them both on so they are one flat of the nut apart. Then I squeeze them together with one hand. Prevents me from slipping and gouging my knuckles and swearing and getting blood all over my work. Also prevents me from overtightening the nut.
Mike Hawkins

knotscott · 03-12-2009, 07:13 PM

The 690 is a solid and well proven performer. It's well balanced, accepts the standard PC bushings, and is great for hand work. It doesn't have variable speed though, which makes it less versatile in the router table than some.

You might also keep your eyes peeled for a Freud FT1700 if you plan to use it in a router table at all. They've been on sale in the $99 range with a plunge and fixed base kit.

The Hitachi M12VC is also a well balanced smaller router that accepts the standard PC bushings. It also has variable speed.

You also can't go wrong if you should find a good sale price on a Milwaukee 5615/5616, Bosch 1617, or DeWalt.

Lots of good routers out there...pick one that feels good in your hands, has the features you like, and a price you're comfortable with.

woodnthings · 03-12-2009, 07:38 PM

This is a question that always comes up and as usual "bigger is better" applies, plunge base is good. variable speed is better since woods vary and router bit diameters require different speeds IE larger diameter requires lower RPMS. The Freud FT1700 or 1702 which comes with both bases was on sale at Woodcraft for $130. It takes 1/2" cutters and has 2 1/4 HP, and is height adjustable from top and bottom for table use. It does require a "special adaptor" for the PC stlye guide bushings which is available from HF for $20 including bushings.. How do I know all this ...been here done this a few times.
You might also check out my other favorite Forum:
www. routerforums.com That's all they do is talk routers, tables, cutters, Hp switches etc. There's one guy bobj3 there with 9977 posts!

And as with all forums,

opinions are many, but good advice is...priceless! bill

kziggy · 03-12-2009, 08:12 PM

As usual, thanks to all for your responses. Plenty to think about. I was thinking of using it with a table at some point, so looking into a variable speed might be smart. Price might dictate purchase at least for this year, but I'm sure I wont go wrong with any of the ones you all have suggested.

Bill, not sure what a "guide bushing" is. I'm a bit new to this so bear with me. Again, thanks.

johnv51 · 03-13-2009, 09:22 AM

I have the PC690 kit with both fixed and plunge bases and does a great job. I would like to get the 890 with the D handle base for the heavier jobs.

john5mt · 03-19-2009, 02:51 AM

Thats a good router to have. I have a bosch1690evs and festool 1400eq. (and yet i am looking at one trying to find one of those old school ones for smaller stuff?)